All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO – Which WordPress SEO Plugin is the Best in 2023?

1. About All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO
2. Starting price & Rating of the plugins
3. Which one is better? – All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO
4. The importance of SEO plugins
5. Verdict: The best SEO plugin for WordPress

All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO – Which one should you choose?

When it comes to optimizing WordPress websites for search engines and social platforms, two plugins stand out from the rest:

• Yoast SEO and All in One SEO.

These plugins have gained immense popularity and are widely regarded as the top choices for increasing the SEO performance of WordPress sites.

In this article, we will compare Yoast SEO and All in One SEO in detail to help you make a decision.

By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which WordPress SEO plugin is the best.

Let’s begin!

About All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO

SEO plugins allow website owners to optimize their sites for search engines easily, providing features.

Both Yoast SEO and AIOSEO has:

• XML sitemaps,
• schema markup,
• robots.txt files,
• URL redirects,
• etc.

Quick comparison of the SEO plugins

Plugin	Starting price	Rating	Key features
All in One SEO	free	4.7 based on 2,000+ reviews	XML sitemaps, Schema.org support, Social media integration, Advanced SEO modules, WooCommerce SEO optimization (Pro)
Yoast SEO	free	4.9 based on 25,000+ reviews	XML sitemaps, Schema.org integration, Readability and content analysis, Breadcrumbs and internal linking, Social media previews

Please note that the starting prices and feature availability may vary based on the plugin version (free or pro) and any updates made by the respective plugin developers.

🧩 Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO is a highly popular and feature-rich WordPress plugin that helps optimize websites for search engines.

It offers tools for on-page optimization, content analysis, XML sitemaps, social media integration, and more SEO tools.

The WordPress SEO plugin is widely recognized for its user-friendly interface.

It also offers a comprehensive set of features, making it a go-to choice for many website owners aiming to improve their SEO performance.

🧩 All in One SEO

All in One SEO is another widely used WordPress plugin designed to enhance the search engine optimization (SEO) of websites.

It provides a range of features including on-page optimization, XML sitemaps, social media integration, and additional SEO tools.

The SEO plugin is known for its simplicity and effectiveness.

This makes it a popular choice among website owners looking to improve their site’s visibility and ranking on search engine results pages.

All in One SEO vs Yoast- Which one is better?

Determining which plugin, All in One SEO or Yoast, is better depends on individual needs and preferences.

Both plugins are highly regarded in the WordPress community and offer comprehensive features for SEO optimization.

Let’s compare them from various perspectives.

1.) Installation and Setup

Search engine optimization requires time and effort to master so you could use it effectively on websites.

For beginners, a WordPress SEO plugin should serve as a valuable tool, simplifying the process and enabling them to apply basic SEO settings effortlessly.

Now, let’s examine how these two plugins compare in terms of installing and configuring essential settings on the WordPress site.

👉Yoast SEO Installation and Setup Guide

To begin, you’ll need to install and activate the Yoast SEO plugin.

Once activated, navigate to SEO » General in your WordPress dashboard and access the configuration wizard located under the Dashboard tab.

Initiating the Yoast SEO Setup Wizard This wizard will guide you through the setup process step by step, ensuring a smooth start even for beginners who might find complex terminology and options overwhelming.

The settings section of Yoast SEO is thoughtfully organized into separate pages, each containing various tabs for specific configurations.

You can find on-screen assistance on every page of Yoast SEO settings.

Simply click the purple question mark button located at the bottom, and it will expand to display support documentation.

👉All in One SEO Installation and Setup Guide

To begin, you’ll need to install and activate the All in One SEO for WordPress plugin.

Once activated, the plugin will automatically launch the setup wizard.

Simply click the ‘Let’s Get Started’ button to proceed.

Compared to Yoast SEO, the setup wizard of All in One SEO comprises fewer steps.

While offering similar options, All in One SEO streamlines the process, particularly for beginners.

All in One SEO Setup We have created a detailed guide that walks you through the entire wizard, ensuring proper setup of All in One SEO.

After completing the wizard, you can access the plugin settings by navigating to All in One SEO » General Settings.

The General Settings page is organized into different sections.

Examples include Search Appearance, Sitemaps, Redirects, and more.

This user-friendly approach simplifies the understanding of settings for beginners.

Completing the wizard alone prepares most websites to effectively utilize All in One SEO for day-to-day tasks.

🏆Winner: All in One SEO for WordPress

Both WordPress plugins offer a wide range of options, aiming to streamline the user experience and facilitate a smooth start.

However, in terms of their setup wizard, we find that between All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO the first one outperforms slightly by providing a more effective and user-friendly experience.

2.) Performing everyday SEO tasks

SEO is a continuous process, where each new post or page added to your website carries its own SEO score.

Consequently, you’ll frequently use your SEO plugin to optimize your content for search engines.

Now, let’s assess All in One SEO vs Yoast in terms of executing day-to-day SEO tasks on your WordPress website.

👉Day to Day SEO Tasks in Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO provides a content analysis tool that assists in optimizing each post or page on your website.

Access it by clicking on the plugin icon located in the top right corner.

Below the post editor, you’ll find the Yoast SEO meta box featuring a snippet preview, focus keyword field, and content analysis

The Google Preview showcases how your site’s SEO title and meta description will appear in search engines.

While Yoast SEO automatically uses your post title and excerpt, we recommend customizing them by simply clicking on the respective fields.

By entering the focus keyword in Yoast SEO, the plugin analyzes your content based on that specific keyword.

The content analysis section displays suggestions from Yoast SEO on enhancing your post’s SEO score.

Switching to the Schema tab allows you to modify the article’s schema markup settings.

Lastly, the social tab lets you set an article image for Facebook and customize your Twitter card.

You can leave the description and title blank since Yoast SEO utilizes your primary SEO title and description in the open graph meta tags.

👉Everyday SEO Tasks in All in One SEO

Unlike Yoast SEO, All in One SEO provides an actual content score known as the TruSEO score.

This feature offers a more actionable approach to optimizing your content.

To begin, edit the desired post or page.

At the top right corner, you’ll find the All in One SEO button displaying the SEO score for that specific content.

Clicking on it expands the content analysis panel.

Additionally, you’ll notice individual scores for each focus keyword. Expanding a keyword reveals suggested actions for improving its score.

Below the post editor, you’ll find AIOSEO settings for each content type.

This is where you can enter your focus keyphrase, title, and description.

A noteworthy feature is the use of Dynamic Tags, allowing you to add dynamic elements to your SEO titles and the meta description.

Examples include current category, current year, current month, and more.

For instance, if your SEO title is “Best WordPress SEO plugins (2023)”, using the current year tag automatically updates it to “Best WordPress SEO plugins (2024)” the following year.

This can enhance your click-through rate in search results, thereby driving more traffic and improving your SEO rankings.

Social tab at All in One SEO

With All in One SEO, you can switch to the Social tab to set a Facebook or Twitter image for your content.

The plugin also enables you to modify the Schema type for individual posts if necessary.

To streamline the process of internal linking, you can utilize the Link Assistant tab to receive automatic suggestions for internal links.

This feature displays the exact phrase and anchor text to which the link will be added.

With just one click, you can incorporate the suggested links into your content.

Furthermore, All in One SEO offers a Site Analysis feature, providing an overall score for your website’s settings.

You can also utilize the Competitor Analysis tool to compare your site with competitors.

🏆Winner: All in One SEO

While both plugins provide convenient options for editing SEO settings on a per-post basis, out of All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO the first takes it a step further.

With its TruSEO score and Focus Keyphrase score, it offers a more actionable approach to optimizing content.

The inclusion of dynamic tags in the title and meta description gives All in One SEO an additional advantage over Yoast SEO.

3.) Indexing and sitemaps functionality

One of the primary responsibilities of an SEO plugin is to facilitate search engines in discovering and indexing your content effectively.

To accomplish this, SEO plugins generate sitemaps, establish connections with webmaster tools, monitor your site’s SEO performance, and perform various other tasks.

Now, let’s examine how All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO address these aspects.

👉Indexing and Sitemaps – Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO takes care of XML sitemap generation automatically for all post types.

To ensure simplicity, it does not have a separate page dedicated to managing or viewing XML sitemaps.

Instead, you can enable or disable XML sitemaps by navigating to the SEO » General page and accessing the ‘Features’ tab.

You do not have the ability to selectively include or exclude specific post types from your XML sitemap within the plugin’s settings.

Furthermore, Yoast SEO provides a convenient feature that allows you to easily verify your website with popular webmaster tools such as Google Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, Baidu, and Yandex.

Moreover, users who subscribe to Yoast SEO Premium have the option to install and activate the Video and News sitemap extensions.

These extensions enable videos and news websites to be prominently featured in search results for video and Google News searches.

👉Indexing and Sitemaps – All in One SEO

Similar to Yoast SEO, All in One SEO automatically generates XML sitemaps for your WordPress website.

However, it offers an advantage by providing a dedicated settings page specifically for managing your XML sitemap.

You can access this page by navigating to All in One SEO » Sitemaps.

Scrolling down, you will discover various settings available for managing your sitemaps.

Within these settings, you have the flexibility to select the specific post types and taxonomies that you wish to include in your sitemaps.

AIOSEO also provides the capability to add custom pages to your sitemap, which is particularly useful if you have a custom landing page that is not built with WordPress.

Similar to Yoast, this SEO plugin allows you to enable Video and News sitemaps as extensions.

Additionally, AIOSEO goes a step further by offering an RSS sitemap feature, providing enhanced functionality for managing your sitemaps.

🏆Winner: All in One SEO

Both Yoast SEO and All in One SEO offer robust functionality for indexing and sitemaps.

Yoast SEO automatically generates XML sitemaps for all post types and provides easy verification for popular webmaster tools.

All in One SEO also generates them automatically and offers a dedicated settings page for managing them.

It allows customization of included post types and taxonomies and supports custom pages in the sitemap.

Additionally, All in One SEO includes extensions for Video and News sitemaps, along with an RSS sitemap feature.

4.) Schema.org integration and support

Schema markup is a unique form of HTML code that enables you to provide search engines with detailed information about the content on your website.

By utilizing schema markup, you can precisely indicate the type of information presented, whether it’s a recipe, blog post, or product page.

This enables search engines to showcase rich snippets in search results, offering users a more comprehensive preview of your content.

👉Schema support with Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO seamlessly incorporates schema metadata into your WordPress posts and pages.

To access the default settings, simply navigate to the SEO » Search Appearance page.

Scroll down to the Knowledge Graph & Schema.org section, where you can indicate whether your website represents an individual or an organization.

Below that, you have the option to provide a name and a logo.

To access additional schema options, switch to the Content Types tab.

Scroll down to the bottom, where you’ll find the default Schema settings for your content types.

If you want to modify the schema type for specific posts and pages, it’s a straightforward process.

Scroll down to the Yoast SEO meta box, and navigate to the Schema tab.

👉All in One SEO schema support

All in One SEO also offers support for schema markup.

You can access the site-wide schema settings in the All in One SEO » Search Appearance page.

In this section, you can provide information such as organization or individual name, logo, phone number, and contact type.

To customize the default schema settings for different content types, you can make changes from this page as well.

Furthermore, All in One SEO provides the Next-Gen Schema Generator, which allows you to set schema settings for individual posts and pages.

Simply navigate to the Schema tab under AIOSEO settings on the post editor screen, and click on the ‘Generate Schema’ button.

This opens the Schema Catalog, where you can choose from various schema types like book, recipe, software, how-to, job posting, FAQ, and more.

Additionally, the plugin includes a local SEO extension, enabling you to optimize your site for local search results.

🏆Winner: All in One SEO

While both plugins offer comprehensive support for schema.org, All in One SEO stands out by making the options more prominently visible.

Its Schema Catalog provides a wide range of schema types, offering greater flexibility and versatility for implementing structured data on your website.

5.) eCommerce functionality

If you operate an online store, organic traffic plays a vital role in generating direct sales. Therefore, eCommerce SEO becomes even more essential for your business’s success.

Now let’s evaluate how both plugins perform for eCommerce websites, regardless of whether they utilize WooCommerce or any other eCommerce plugin.

👉eCommerce Support – Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO supports eCommerce websites and offers a separate plugin for WooCommerce called Yoast WooCommerce SEO.

It allows you to optimize product titles, descriptions and generates a product category XML map.

The WooCommerce SEO plugin provides additional features to enhance the optimization of your product pages.

👉eCommerce support – All in One SEO

All in One SEO for WordPress provides extensive eCommerce support, automatically identifying products and applying the correct Product schema markup.

The SEO plugin allows you to enhance your eCommerce schema data, including brand, colors, and manufacturer details for each product.

Additionally, it generates XML maps for your products and categories.

Even if you’re using a simple order form instead of a shopping cart plugin, you can optimize the page as a product by editing it and changing the schema type to Product in the settings.

🏆Winner: All in One SEO

While Yoast SEO offers additional eCommerce support through an extension, All in One SEO stands out by providing comprehensive eCommerce features out of the box.

It allows you to optimize product pages without the need to install an eCommerce plugin, making it a more convenient choice for online stores.

6.) Bonus SEO tools and features

On-page SEO is a multifaceted process, and both of these plugins offer a range of tools and features beyond just meta titles.

These additional features aim to provide a comprehensive all-in-one solution, eliminating the necessity of installing multiple SEO plugins.

👉Yoast SEO:

• Breadcrumb Navigation
• Open Graph Meta Tags
• Importing Data from Google Webmaster Tools
• Built-in robots.txt and .htaccess editor
• Import/Export SEO data
• Redirects Manager

👉All in One SEO:

• Breadcrumbs Navigation
• Open Graph Meta Tags
• Robots.txt and .htaccess editor
• Import and Export SEO Data
• Redirects Manager
• Headline Analyzer
• ChatGPT AI Tools
• SEO Search Statistics
• Keyword Rank Tracking
• 404 Error Tracking

🏆Our winner is All in One SEO again

When comparing the two, All in One SEO offers a cleaner interface and a wider range of additional features, making it the preferred choice over Yoast SEO.

7.) Pricing comparison: All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO

Pricing is an important consideration for users, as both plugins offer limited free versions with the option to upgrade for additional features and support.

👉Yoast SEO Pricing:

• Single site license for Yoast SEO Premium: $99, with increasing costs for additional sites
• Extensions like WooCommerce SEO, Local, News, and Video SEO: $79 for a single site
• Subscription plan: $229/year for all extensions, limited to one website (additional subscriptions required for each additional website)

👉All in One SEO Pricing:

• Free version with limited support and features
• Paid plan starting at $49.60 for a single site with one year of support and updates
• Best value plan: $199.60, includes all add-ons and features for up to 10 sites

🏆The winner in terms of pricing is All in One SEO

While the pricing for a single website is similar to Yoast SEO, All in One SEO’s Pro plan allows for up to 10 websites, making it a more cost-effective choice.

The importance of SEO plugins

SEO plugins play a crucial role in optimizing websites for search engines.

They provide a range of tools and features to improve on-page SEO, such as optimizing meta tags, generating XML maps, managing schema markup, analyzing keyword usage, and more.

These plugins help enhance website visibility, increase organic traffic, and improve search engine rankings.

By implementing SEO best practices and utilizing the features offered by these plugins, website owners can effectively optimize their content.

They can also improve user experience and attract more targeted visitors to their WordPress website.

All in One SEO vs Yoast – Verdict

Both All in One SEO and Yoast SEO are highly regarded plugins, making a close comparison between the two necessary.

However, All in One SEO emerges as the winner due to its ease of use, superior user experience, and greater control over various features.

All in One SEO excels in areas such as eCommerce SEO, schema support for eCommerce, and Local SEO.

The on-site SEO Audit and TruSEO score features offered by All in One SEO provide beginners with actionable plans to enhance their content and improve their SEO efforts.

Moreover, if you manage multiple websites, All in One SEO gives significant cost savings.

We hope this comparison of Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO has assisted you in finding the best WordPress SEO plugin for your website.

Frequently Asked Questions