Categories Blog For Businesses
Categories • Food, Beverages & Tobacco • Bakery • Crumbly Cafe & Bakery
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery

crumblynyc.com

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery Reviews

EXCELLENT rating
4.9
251 reviews Verified

crumblynyc.com

Visit this website
%title%

%offer%

Write a review

Reviews ( 251 ) 4.9

Genevieve Javidzad
Genevieve Javidzad
2025.04.09
I ordered my 30th birthday cake from here and it was absolutely perfect! The team at Crumbly worked with me to bring my exact vision to light, were patient as I went back and forth on revisions to my idea, and ultimately the cake not only came out looking perfect, but it tasted delicious too! It was a pleasure to work with them from start to finish (shout out to Mia for all her help), and I will definitely order from them again! Thank you Crumbly!
Food
Service
I ordered my 30th birthday cake from here and it was absolutely perfect! The team at Crumbly worked with me to bring my exact vision to light, were patient as I went back and forth on revisions to my idea, and ultimately the cake not only came out looking perfect, but it tasted delicious too! It was a pleasure to work with them from start to finish (shout out to Mia for all her help), and I will definitely order from them again! Thank you Crumbly!
Report
zumi tt
zumi tt
2025.03.30
Highly recommend the Crumbly bakery. Their custom order cakes are delicious!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Highly recommend the Crumbly bakery. Their custom order cakes are delicious!
Report
Sawyer DeVuyst
Sawyer DeVuyst
2025.03.29
Love this bakery! Yummy sweet treats and kind servers!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Love this bakery! Yummy sweet treats and kind servers!
Report
Valeria Jones
Valeria Jones
2025.03.28
Best cakes ever, nailed every time!
Report
winifer estevez
winifer estevez
2025.03.26
I placed an order for my mother's 54th Birthday, THEY DID AN AMAZING Job and the cake and cupcakes were delicious 😋. Super affordable.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
I placed an order for my mother's 54th Birthday, THEY DID AN AMAZING Job and the cake and cupcakes were delicious 😋. Super affordable. I placed an order for my mother's 54th Birthday, THEY DID AN AMAZING Job and the cake and cupcakes were delicious 😋. Super affordable.
Report
Steph W
Steph W
2025.03.24
Everything in this bakery looks scrumptious! Based on the name of the establishment and the accolades posted on their walls, I had to try their crumb cake for $4.90. It was absolutely divine! The perfect amount of sweetness and the cake was super moist. The crumb topping was not super delicate unlike other crumb cakes so each bite was sufficiently enjoyable. Definitely coming back!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Aaron Jacobs
Aaron Jacobs
2025.03.23
Crumbly is my go to place for birthday cakes, cupcakes and any other sweet treats. Recently had them make a custom cake for my father in laws 70th, the cake was outstanding in looks and taste! They really take pride in what they do and don’t disappoint. Thanks again for creating this beautiful cake for a special occasion!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Crumbly is my go to place for birthday cakes, cupcakes and any other sweet treats. Recently had them make a custom cake for my father in laws 70th, the cake was outstanding in looks and taste! They really take pride in what they do and don’t disappoint. Thanks again for creating this beautiful cake for a special occasion! Crumbly is my go to place for birthday cakes, cupcakes and any other sweet treats. Recently had them make a custom cake for my father in laws 70th, the cake was outstanding in looks and taste! They really take pride in what they do and don’t disappoint. Thanks again for creating this beautiful cake for a special occasion!
Report
Alexander Wilson
Alexander Wilson
2025.03.23
Amazing cakes and excellent coffee. Can’t recommend enough!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Amazing cakes and excellent coffee. Can’t recommend enough!
Report
Angelique Pierre
Angelique Pierre
2025.03.23
best coffee i’ve had in a while!! and the people who work there are so sweet!! will definitely be returning <3
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Lia Maerefat
Lia Maerefat
2025.03.22
Food
Service
Report
Sonya Payne
Sonya Payne
2025.03.16
The best cakes, scones and coffee in mid town East. Super friendly and know their regulars well. ❤️❤️❤️
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
M M
M M
2025.03.16
Crumbly is a wonderful addition to this neighborhood! The cappuccino is a MUST - one of the best I’ve ever had. To go with that nectar of the gods, their savories and sweets are divine. The turkey and cheese on croissant is perfect for lunch, and the cheesecakes, cookies and large cakes are like ambrosia. You cannot go wrong with your selection here, and Crumbly bakes ALL DAY LONG so everything is exceedingly fresh, unlike so many others throughout the City.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Avery DePaola
Avery DePaola
2025.03.12
Chocolate peanut butter cookie was perfection
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Bianca Mancinelli
Bianca Mancinelli
2025.03.09
Working with Mia and Crumbly was an absolute pleasure! Everything was delicious, delivery was on time and arrived in perfect condition, and Mia was so creative and helpful in our order. Never oversold anything - was honest, respected our needs, listened to our thoughts, and came up with the perfect cake and cupcake display for our celebration! I couldn't be more pleased and enthusiastic!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Jasmin Onus
Jasmin Onus
2025.03.08
Extremely happy with our Bluey themed cake! Excellent service and affordable price.

The whole process from ordering to collection was easy and convenient. We literally ordered this cake two days prior to the birthday, paid online and collected. Our daughter is obsessed with this cake!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Extremely happy with our Bluey themed cake! Excellent service and affordable price. The whole process from ordering to collection was easy and convenient. We literally ordered this cake two days prior to the birthday, paid online and collected. Our daughter is obsessed with this cake!
Report
katherine rosado
katherine rosado
2025.03.08
They have the best Oreo cheesecake l've ever tried. the packaging is so cute and the atmosphere is so warming and welcoming. service was fast and efficient will definitely come again.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Lexi Fliegel
Lexi Fliegel
2025.03.08
Gorgeous cake and we had such productive calls beforehand to make sure the vision came to life!!!! Will be back.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Gorgeous cake and we had such productive calls beforehand to make sure the vision came to life!!!! Will be back. Gorgeous cake and we had such productive calls beforehand to make sure the vision came to life!!!! Will be back.
Report
Grace Marie Scaglione
Grace Marie Scaglione
2025.03.07
We love Crumbly! All the treats are excellent & the owner treats all the customers as friends. He is so kind to the neighborhood children. Coffee is top notch, Nutella pie is a stand out, and brownies are beyond!!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report
Rory Quinn
Rory Quinn
2025.03.05
Our favorite local bakery. Everything they make is amazing, and their coffee is great. We go every weekend, and the staff is so incredibly friendly. They almost always give our dog a pup cup. They also baked our first-anniversary cake, and it was even better than our actual wedding cake.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Our favorite local bakery. Everything they make is amazing, and their coffee is great. We go every weekend, and the staff is so incredibly friendly. They almost always give our dog a pup cup. They also baked our first-anniversary cake, and it was even better than our actual wedding cake. Our favorite local bakery. Everything they make is amazing, and their coffee is great. We go every weekend, and the staff is so incredibly friendly. They almost always give our dog a pup cup. They also baked our first-anniversary cake, and it was even better than our actual wedding cake. Our favorite local bakery. Everything they make is amazing, and their coffee is great. We go every weekend, and the staff is so incredibly friendly. They almost always give our dog a pup cup. They also baked our first-anniversary cake, and it was even better than our actual wedding cake.
Report
jbreviews
jbreviews
2025.03.02
Ordered a slice of cake. It was somewhat dry and crumbly, like it had been sitting out for a while. (To be fair, it may have been—this was in the afternoon.) Even the frosting, while the moistest part of the cake, was a little dry. Ate about half and then ended up not finishing the rest. Cost about $8.75. Service seemed friendly at first but gave a sort of sarcastic thank-you when I declined to tip on the card reader.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Report